TARF Expert Blog Post
It's time to start including sleep assessments in student evaluations
Dr. William M Hang, DDS, MSD
There is a strong connection between learning challenges and poor sleep that some in the medical/dental profession have recognized, but far too many have not. A sleep test should be at the top of the list of things to consider when any child is not doing well in school. Adults who don’t sleep well at night, doze very easily during the day. Kids who don’t sleep well paradoxically are often hyperactive and that also should be a sign to look for a sleep problem.
A quick internet check indicates that in 2021 the federal government awarded states over $13 billion in IDEA grants to provide special education services. My guess is that such spending is on a steep uphill trajectory with more kids affected and more kids being diagnosed. If we listen to authorities like Ronald Harper, PhD (Neurobiologist at UCLA) and Dr. David Gozal (Past President of the American Thoracic Society and author of hundreds of papers on sleep/breathing/learning, etc.) we know that many children are getting permanent brain damage from reduced oxygen saturation long before they enter a school for the first time. If one looks at many of the studies from these experts, and others, it is sad to be spending such large sums of money on treating a problem which might be prevented. We are really dealing with fighting fire vs. preventing fire.
In my practice I had an 11 year old boy RECOGNIZED and REFERRED by a summer camp counselor for a sleep problem which was diagnosed as severe OSA. The child had been seeing the pediatrician his whole life, but no one recognized the problem. By the time we saw him he was struggling and not doing well in school. I’m not qualified to diagnose sleep/breathing disorders, nor am I qualified to diagnose brain damage. Having said that, it was obvious to me and his mother that he had sustained brain damage that was affecting his performance in school. At this point, I suspect he will NOT do well in life no matter what is done!
Early recognition might have prevented this from becoming a lifelong challenge for this young man. Dr. David Gozal has cited permanent brain damage causing a 10 point drop in IQ for a child with OSA early in childhood. As Dr. Gozal has stated, that gap can be the difference between a college education and no college education. There are other studies which indicate that a 15 point drop in IQ is not unusual with undiagnosed OSA in children. These figures should be a call for early recognition and treatment of sleep/breathing problems when testing confirms these problems exist.
Is there treatment which can prevent these problems? It depends on who you ask. Many in the traditional orthodontic arena would say emphatically “no”. I’ve treated a 4 year old boy who flew from Chicago to Los Angeles many times for me to develop his face forward to open his airway. He had been diagnosed with OSA, Failure to Thrive, and Pierre-Robin Sequence which results in poor forward development of the face. Using a very challenging technique involving removable orthodontic appliances, we first developed his upper jaw forward about 6-8 mm and then developed his lower jaw forward to meet the upper. In a little over a year of this treatment the Chicago sleep physician called me to tell me that our mutual patient had recently had a sleep test indicating he no longer suffered from OSA. Years later when this boy was in late high school I contacted his mother, and she reported him prospering, doing well in school, having grown more normally, and being an aggressive tennis player. As she indicated to me, none of this would have happened without this intervention. This boy is now in college.
If it worked for one child do you think it might work for others? How many more thousands of kids are sitting in classrooms, performing poorly, getting teased, and acting out their frustrations because no one has recognized these issues? It is so easy to see and, frankly, simple to diagnose. Dr. Christian Guilleminault who headed the Stanford University sleep clinic and authored more than 400 articles published in the refereed medical literature on sleep issues stated we need to treat these problems “as soon as they are recognized”. We owe our kids this better future.
Dr. Bill Hang- founder Ortho2Health ortho2health.com
The information in this article is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health care provider with any questions you may have.