---
title: 'When CPAP Wasn’t Enough'
description: 'Carol used CPAP for years while her sleep apnea grew worse. She and a friend describe how it affected her life, and her surgeon explains the options…'
canonical: 'https://airwayrevolution.org/video-stories/carols-story-when-cpap-wasnt-enough'
type: video_story
published: '2026-11-17'
updated: '2026-11-11T00:46:05+00:00'
keywords:
  - CPAP
audiences:
  - Adults
  - Parents
  - Teachers
duration: '12:43'
members_only: false
---

# When CPAP Wasn’t Enough

Carol used CPAP for years while her sleep apnea grew worse. She and a friend describe how it affected her life, and her surgeon explains the options beyond CPAP.

## Transcript

Carol Kardisco: My name is Carol. I was a psychotherapist for many years, but I'm retired now.

Friend: She's a marvelous woman and a very giving woman, and she's always was constantly moving. She took care of her mother, she had her grandchildren here all the time, and her love for her dogs is just—it's just wonderful.

Carol: I was on a CPAP for many years. Started off mild and then it just kept progressing mild to moderate.

Friend: But she was really becoming more concerned because it wasn't helping her.

Carol: I was basically not functioning. My AHI—no breath, if you know what that is, so many times you stop breathing—was 48 times per hour through the night, and I was totally sleep-deprived. It affected family relationships, social relationships. I couldn't walk my dogs. I had no energy to walk my dogs or interact with them too much.

The sleep apnea got so bad that when I would get with friends—we have a little group that we would get together once a week and have lunch together, things like that—we'd be sitting around talking and they'd be waking me up saying, "Carol, you're falling asleep." I was falling asleep. You know, we're sitting around talking and I'm falling asleep on them.

Friend: I didn't know what was going on. We were having a conversation and suddenly Carol wasn't part of it anymore. You get scared because you don't know what's happening to someone that's sitting across the table from you.

Carol: I was doing weird things. Like one day I found my hairdryer in the refrigerator. I found toothpaste in the electrical outlet. I mean, I think bizarre behaviors because of the lack of sleep.

When it got really bad, I didn't drive. I limited my driving. Couldn't go for groceries, couldn't run errands, couldn't go out with friends. Everything I needed to do, doctor appointments or whatever, I got tired of asking people, "Can you drive me here? Can you drive me there?"

My son sat me down one day and he said, "Mom, something's very wrong." He said, "You need to go somewhere. You need to find somebody who can help you, because this is not helping you. This is not right. You're getting tired and you're having trouble functioning day-to-day. It's not good." He researched things and actually sent me a link. He said, "Here's somebody I just found who treats this." And it was Dr. Dedhia.

Dr. Raj Dedhia: My name is Raj Dedhia. I'm the Director of Sleep Surgery at the University of Pennsylvania. Carol came to me from about an hour away and she said, "You know, I've heard about you. I wanted to see what we could do for Inspire." She had sort of heard about the commercials and that kind of thing.

We did our usual workup and one of the things that struck me was that she was really sleepy and she couldn't drive. She actually had messaged me saying, "I can't drive anymore." She's an independent person, and she said, "I can't drive." I said, "Okay." And we went down the pathway. She had clear sleep apnea. I read her sleep study, I did the sleep endoscopy. She was going to be a very good candidate based on her tongue position and her collapsibility measure of her soft palate.

And I said, "We can offer this to you, but Carol, I'm not sure it's going to help you in the way that you want. I don't know how much better you're going to feel with the sleepiness. It's certainly part of this, but I don't know that."

Carol: After I had that, I had a session with him and my son was with me. He did a slide presentation explaining the results and showed me what was happening when I was trying to sleep. My airway was completely collapsing, like just darkness in there. Everything was totally blocked.

Even my son, when he sat me down, he said, "Look, they're not getting to the—there's a problem somewhere and they're putting a band-aid on it, or trying this and trying that, but they're not getting to the root cause. There's a root cause going on here and nobody's getting to that." And that's what Dr. Dedhia was able to do very quickly is find out what the problem was.

Dr. Raj Dedhia: People are using CPAP, but they don't feel better. They have documented sleep apnea; it goes away with CPAP, but they don't feel better. CPAP usually is going to treat any obstruction other than maybe the epiglottis because of its action like a lever.

The surgery was to implant an Inspire device, which is called a hypoglossal nerve stimulator. Hypoglossal nerve stimulation is a type of therapy for sleep apnea. Inspire is an FDA-approved device, and this works by a battery called an implantable pulse generator that's implanted on the right side, typically of the chest. There is a sensing lead that's attached to this device that detects breathing. So when you breathe in and breathe out, the pressure sensor can detect what you're doing. And then the third piece is a stimulation cuff that's tunneled under the skin into the neck. So when the patient's breathing at night, this fires and gives the tongue some movement to stay out of the airway.

Carol: Oh, it's very simple. There's a remote, and when you're ready to go to bed, you turn the remote on. In the morning, you turn it off and it just starts doing its thing.

I had a follow-up sleep study, and this sleep study was fantastic. Dr. Dedhia was overjoyed. I went from an AHI of 48 down to between 1 and 5. He was totally amazed.

I feel like a new person now. I can do things that I wasn't doing before. I'm walking my dogs, I'm doing all kinds of things. I'm happy that I can drive for one thing. You have no idea.

Dr. Raj Dedhia: She asked for my permission again: "Can I drive? Do you think I'm safe to drive?" I talked to her and I said, "Start with short distances, but if you're okay, yeah." And, you know, I actually saw her today and she was saying, "Yeah, I can drive myself to and from these hour-long visits."

Carol: So I'm very happy that I can be independent again.

Friend: After the surgery, she was a whole different person. She smiled more, she had so much more energy, she was looking forward to things more. You know, I'm just so happy for her that she had this surgery and that it changed her life. She has a better quality of life now than she had two years ago.

Carol: This summer I did a lot around my house. I refinished my deck, power washed my house, and re-landscaped my property. I planted—I mean, I did all kinds of things that I couldn't do.

My son is so happy that I finally did something about going to a higher level and came to see Dr. Dedhia and had the surgery. He's just really happy to see me feeling so much better.

And that's the thing about this practice: it gives people hope that something else can be done that can be as effective, and you're not a failure—you have options.

Dr. Raj Dedhia: You've got to get the data to figure out what's the source of the obstruction. And now with new therapies, people like Carol can be helped.

Carol: I often think this: I feel like Dr. Dedhia has saved my life.
